New York's CSSA and Mediation: A Custom Child Support Guide

For divorcing or separating parents in New York, the issue of child support is often the most critical and, frequently, the most contentious. New York law provides a clear framework for calculating this obligation: the Child Support Standards Act (CSSA). The CSSA establishes a presumptively correct amount of support to ensure children maintain a standard of living commensurate with their parents' resources, even after separation.

However, the CSSA is a formula, not a tailor-made solution. It does not perfectly address the complexities of every modern family, particularly those with high incomes, special needs children, or significantly shared custody arrangements. This is where divorce mediation becomes invaluable.

Mediation provides the necessary flexibility to navigate the CSSA's rigid guidelines, allowing parents to apply the law in a way that truly works for their unique circumstances. By understanding the CSSA's foundation, its limitations, and the ten factors that permit deviation, parents can use mediation to craft a financial blueprint for their children’s future that is both legally sound and practically workable. This guide will clarify the CSSA and demonstrate how mediation transforms a rigid formula into a comprehensive, customized child support plan.

The Foundation: What is the CSSA Formula?

The Child Support Standards Act (CSSA), codified in the Domestic Relations Law and Family Court Act, is New York's primary mechanism for calculating child support. It operates on a predictable, three-step formula designed to ensure both parents contribute their proportionate share of financial support.

1. Determining "Adjusted" Combined Parental Income

The first step is calculating the combined parental income. This is not simply the total of the parents' gross salaries. The CSSA defines "gross income" broadly, including wages, self-employment income, benefits, and even imputed income (what a parent could be earning). From this gross total, several allowable deductions are made, most notably:

FICA (Social Security and Medicare) taxes paid.
New York City or Yonkers income taxes paid.
Spousal maintenance (alimony) paid to a new spouse (if pursuant to a court order or written agreement).
Child support paid for children from other relationships.

The final figure is the Adjusted Gross Income for each parent, which is then combined.

2. Applying the Statutory Percentage

The CSSA applies a statutory percentage to the combined parental income, which varies based on the number of children:

Number of Children Statutory Percentage

One Child ………………………………. 17%

Two Children ………………………………. 25%

Three Children……………………………. 29%

Four Children ……………………………… 31%

Five or More Children…………………. At least 35%

This percentage is applied to the combined income up to a statutory cap, which is currently set at $183,000 (as of March 1, 2024, and subject to periodic adjustments). This figure establishes the Basic Child Support Obligation.

3. Calculating Each Parent’s Pro-Rata Share

The final step is to determine each parent's pro-rata (proportional) share of the Basic Child Support Obligation. If Parent A earns 60% of the combined adjusted income and Parent B earns 40%, Parent A is responsible for 60% of the basic obligation, and Parent B is responsible for 40%. The non-custodial parent (the one with the lesser amount of residential time) then pays their share to the custodial parent.

What is the Problem with the CSSA Formula?

The CSSA is powerful because it provides certainty and consistency. However, a formula by its nature struggles with individual complexity. The CSSA creates three common problem areas where litigation often arises, but mediation excels:

A. The Income Cap Problem

The formula automatically applies only to the first $183,000 of combined parental income. For parents whose combined income exceeds this amount (high-net-worth families), the court has discretion: it can apply the statutory percentages to income above the cap, or it can set an amount based on the children's actual needs and the parties' pre-divorce lifestyle.

The Mediation Advantage: In mediation, parents retain control. They can agree to cap the income at a number higher than the statutory amount (e.g., $250,000 or $300,000) or agree to a flat-rate deviation for the amount above the cap. This eliminates the risk and expense of a judge making a discretionary decision after reviewing expensive lifestyle evidence.

B. The Add-Ons: Mandatory vs. Discretionary Expenses

The Basic Child Support Obligation is intended to cover essentials (food, clothing, shelter). It does not cover all of a child’s expenses. The CSSA requires parents to divide certain Mandatory Add-Ons on a pro-rata basis:

Childcare Expenses: Costs related to the parents working or attending school.
Health Insurance Premiums & Unreimbursed Medical Expenses: Costs related to the child’s health.

The Mediation Advantage: The CSSA is silent on discretionary expenses like private school tuition, extracurricular activities (sports, music lessons), tutoring, and college savings. Mediation allows parents to:

Establish a Clear Funding Mechanism: Create a dedicated joint account for "add-ons," or set a clear procedure for reimbursement.
Address Discretionary Costs: Determine in advance whether and how future costs like college tuition will be addressed, often far exceeding the basic CSSA guidelines. This foresight creates stability.

C. The Shared Custody Problem

The CSSA assumes there is one custodial parent and one non-custodial parent. It provides no statutory adjustment for shared physical custody (e.g., a 50/50 or 60/40 parenting schedule). For child support purposes, the "custodial parent" is typically the one with the lower income, who then receives the payment from the higher-earning parent.

The Mediation Advantage: Mediation allows parents to acknowledge the financial reality of shared custody. Since the higher-earning parent with shared custody is likely already paying many expenses when the child is with them, mediation can justify a downward deviation from the strict CSSA guidelines. The parents can agree to:

Adjust the pro-rata shares.
Establish a "set-off" calculation to account for shared expenses.
Create a mechanism for directly paying shared costs

How Can Mediation Justify Deviating from the CSSA?

The CSSA requires that the basic guideline amount be calculated and stated in the final settlement agreement. If parents agree to an amount different from the guidelines (a deviation), their agreement must:

Explicitly state the CSSA guideline amount.
Explain the reasons for the deviation.

The CSSA itself provides ten factors that a court considers when determining if the guideline amount is "unjust or inappropriate," allowing parents to use these as legally valid justifications for deviation in mediation.

What are the Ten Factors for Deviation?

Financial resources of the child and the parents.
The child's physical, emotional, and special educational needs and aptitudes.
The standard of living the child would have enjoyed if the parents had not separated (crucial for high-income families).
Tax consequences.
Non-monetary contributions (e.g., a parent caring for the child more than expected).
Educational needs of either parent.
Extraordinary costs associated with visitation (e.g., long-distance travel).
The disparity in parents' incomes.
The needs of other children a parent is supporting.
Any other factor the court deems relevant.

Mediation uses these factors as a legal roadmap to negotiate a fair, customized outcome. For instance, parents with shared custody can use Factor 5 (non-monetary contributions) and Factor 7 (extraordinary visitation costs, even if minor) to justify a deviation that reflects their actual sharing of daily expenses. This process transforms a rigid legal mandate into a flexible family solution. For a comprehensive look at the overall divorce process, please see our guide on What is Divorce Mediation.

CTA Box

Don't let a rigid formula determine your child's future. Mediation allows you to use the CSSA guidelines to build a sustainable, fair child support plan. Schedule a confidential consultation to understand how we can customize the CSSA for your family.

Schedule Your Consultation

Practical Steps to Mediating CSSA

A structured mediation process ensures that the resulting child support agreement is legally compliant and durable:

Step 1: Full Financial Disclosure is Essential

Before any negotiation, both parents must fully and transparently disclose their income, assets, debts, and allowable deductions. Without accurate CSSA calculations, any resulting agreement is legally flawed. The mediator ensures both parties have the same reliable data (tax returns, W-2s, etc.) to calculate the official guideline amount.

Step 2: Calculate the CSSA Guideline Amount

The mediator works with the parents to mechanically calculate the presumed basic obligation, including the pro-rata shares for the mandatory add-ons. Even if the parents intend to deviate, this figure serves as the mandatory baseline that must be stated in the final agreement.

Step 3: Negotiate the Deviation and Rationale

This is where mediation shines. Parents discuss their family's unique needs (e.g., private school, special needs therapy, travel for extracurriculars). They agree on a revised total support amount and/or a method for handling expenses, then select the relevant CSSA factors (the "Ten Factors") that legally justify their choice.

Step 4: Finalizing the Enforceable Agreement

The mediator documents the agreement in a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), which clearly states the initial CSSA calculation, the final agreed-upon support amount, and the detailed reasons for the deviation. This MOU is then used by the review attorneys to draft the final, legally enforceable Marital Settlement Agreement or Divorce Stipulation. This due diligence ensures the court will approve the agreement because it meets the CSSA's strict disclosure requirements.

How Does a Customized Plan Benefit Your Family?

By using mediation to navigate the CSSA, parents achieve results that traditional litigation rarely delivers:

Financial Predictability: Agreements are tailored to the family’s real-world budgets, reducing stress and future arguments.
Reduced Conflict: Parents design a flexible spending system for the discretionary add-ons (like camp or college), eliminating the need to argue over every new expense.
Legal Durability: By explicitly stating the CSSA guidelines and the reasons for deviation, the agreement is less vulnerable to being challenged or rejected by a judge down the line.
Focus on the Child: The discussion centers on the child’s specific needs (Factor 2) and maintaining the appropriate standard of living (Factor 3), rather than simply applying a blanket percentage.

The CSSA provides the law, but mediation provides the wisdom and flexibility to apply that law successfully to your life. For assistance with all other family law matters, our Divorce Mediation Services are designed to support your family's needs.

CTA Box

Secure a financial future for your children that is stable and equitable. Work with a New York mediator who deeply understands the Child Support Standards Act and the nuances of deviation. Begin creating your custom child support plan today.

Schedule Your Free 15-Min Call

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What is the Child Support Standards Act (CSSA)?

The CSSA is a New York law (DRL § 240 and FCA § 413) that provides a mandatory formula for calculating the presumptively correct amount of child support based on the parents' combined income and the number of children.

2. What is the current CSSA income cap?

The CSSA formula is automatically applied only to the parents' combined income up to a statutory cap of $183,000 (as of March 1, 2024). Income above this cap is subject to judicial or parental discretion.

3. Can parents agree to pay less than the CSSA guideline amount?

Yes, but the agreement must follow strict rules: it must explicitly state the CSSA guideline amount and provide legally valid reasons (using the "Ten Factors") for the parents' decision to deviate from that amount. Without this written rationale, the agreement may be rejected by the court.

4. Does the CSSA formula account for shared physical custody?

No. The CSSA formula assumes one custodial and one non-custodial parent and does not automatically reduce the amount for shared custody. However, in mediation, parents can use one or more of the "Ten Factors" (such as extraordinary visitation expenses or income disparity) to justify a deviation that reflects their shared financial responsibilities. Hence, it’s a significant opportunity to create your own agreement in mediation.

5. What are the "Mandatory Add-Ons" in the CSSA?

Mandatory Add-Ons are expenses that are generally divided pro rata (proportionally) between the parents, in addition to the basic support obligation. These include childcare costs necessary for the custodial parent to work or attend school, as well as health insurance premiums and the child's unreimbursed medical expenses.